magier vs Designity

Choosing between magier and Designity comes down to what kind of creative partner your team needs. One gives you a production team that moves fast on design and Webflow work. The other gives you a Creative Director who leads strategy, assigns specialists, and manages the creative process on your behalf. They overlap on services but differ on how the work gets done, what's included, and what it costs.

Beyond pricing and reviews, we compare magier and Designity on services, creative direction, Webflow development, turnaround speed, and contract flexibility to help you find the right fit for your budget and needs.

magier vs Designity at a glance

‍

The biggest structural difference is who leads the work. At magier, your art director coordinates the team, provides creative oversight, and reviews every design before delivery. Designity's Creative Director takes on a broader strategic role that includes campaign concepting, specialist assignment, and marketing strategy.

What is magier?

magier is a creative subscription service that provides graphic design and Webflow development to businesses on a monthly basis. Founded by Sina Sadegh and Maximilian Fleitmann, both with 10+ years of experience building startups and scaling companies, magier positions itself as an extended design and development team. The company has served 150+ brands, holds a 4.9/5 rating across 105 Trustpilot reviews, and is a Webflow Premium Partner.

Every client gets a dedicated team led by an art director who also manages the project. Under the art director, a team of designers and/or Webflow developers handles the actual production work, depending on the scope of your subscription.

Key services:

• Graphic design subscription (€2,750/month): unlimited tasks across ad creatives, brand design, UI/UX, web design, illustrations, presentations, social media, packaging, and motion design, with one active task at a time and results delivered within 48 hours
• Webflow development subscription (€2,750/month): new landing pages, complex sections, custom development, CMS work, integrations, and migrations, built by in-house Webflow developers
• Combined design + Webflow subscription (€4,450/month): both pipelines under one team, with the design-to-Webflow handoff managed internally
• One-time projects: for teams not ready for a subscription, magier also offers one-off design or Webflow projects with a fixed scope and deadline, suited for larger work like a full rebrand, website redesign, or Webflow migration

Target audience: startups, scaleups, SaaS companies, and marketing teams that need ongoing design and Webflow work without hiring in-house or coordinating multiple freelancers. Clients range from early-stage startups to companies with thousands of employees across SaaS, fintech, ecommerce, and Web3.

{{cta}}

‍

What is Designity?

Designity is a US-based Creative-as-a-Service (CaaS) platform that pairs every client with a dedicated Creative Director who leads a curated team of specialists. Founded in 2012, Designity positions itself between a traditional agency and an unlimited design subscription by adding a strategic leadership layer on top of creative production. The company holds a 4.5/5 rating across 112 Trustpilot reviews and a 4.7/5 across 31 G2 reviews, and claims its talent pool represents the top 1% of US-based creative professionals.

Key services:

• Design, web, and motion production: brand design, graphic design, illustration, web design, UI/UX, front-end development, motion graphics, video editing, and presentation design, all managed through a Creative Director
• Content and marketing services: copywriting, SEO, content marketing, email marketing, ABM (account-based marketing), and marketing audit and strategy, included under the same subscription
• Creative leadership: every plan includes a dedicated Creative Director, a Project Manager, and a Marketing Strategist, with the CD acting as the single point of contact and quality gatekeeper

Target audience: mid-market marketing teams, B2B SaaS companies, and growth-stage organizations that need strategic creative direction alongside production, particularly those without an in-house Creative Director. Designity requires US time zone availability and targets companies with $5,000+/month creative budgets.

Services and scope compared

‍

Designity covers more ground, particularly on the marketing and content side. If your team needs copywriting, SEO strategy, and marketing audits alongside design production, Designity bundles all of that into one subscription. magier does not offer these as standalone services.

magier's advantage is depth over breadth in two areas.

1. Webflow: if your website runs on Webflow and you need both design and development, magier handles the full workflow from brief to live page under one team. Designity offers general web design and front-end development but does not position itself as a Webflow-specific partner.
2. Flexibility: magier offers one-time projects for teams that need a specific deliverable (a rebrand, a Webflow site, a website redesign) without committing to a monthly subscription. Designity does not offer project-based work outside its subscription plans.

Pricing and total cost of ownership

‍

magier costs roughly half of what Designity charges for design work. The gap narrows when you factor in what Designity includes that magier does not: a Creative Director, a Marketing Strategist, and services like copywriting and SEO. If you need those extras, Designity's price reflects a broader scope. If you don't, you're paying for capabilities you won't use.

Designity's hour-based model also introduces a ceiling. The Plus plan includes 120 hours per month. If your workload consistently exceeds that, you're either upgrading to Premium or buying add-on creative capacity at $395 to $895 per week. magier's unlimited-tasks model has no hour cap, but it processes one task at a time per pipeline, so throughput depends on task complexity and the 48-hour cycle.

For teams that aren't sure about a subscription yet, magier also offers one-time projects with a fixed scope and deadline. This gives you a way to evaluate the team and the quality before committing monthly. Designity's 2-week trial serves a similar purpose, though the trial has a copyright forfeiture clause if you cancel (more on that in the risk section).

Turnaround and delivery speed

‍

magier's turnaround model is simpler and more predictable: submit a brief, get first results in 48 hours, iterate on the same cycle. If most of your requests are individual deliverables (an ad creative, a landing page design, a social media set), this cadence works well.

Designity's turnaround is more project-oriented. The Creative Director builds a custom timeline with milestones for each project, which gives you more visibility into complex, multi-step work but makes the delivery pace less uniform. Some G2 reviews note that the onboarding process can take longer than expected, with one reviewer mentioning that the 2-week trial period was largely consumed by meetings and kickoff calls rather than production work (source: G2, Designity pricing page reviews).

Design quality and vetting

‍

This is Designity's biggest differentiator. The Creative Director model means someone is actively thinking about your brand at a strategic level, not just executing briefs. If your team does not have an internal Creative Director and wants that layer of strategic oversight without hiring one ($120,000+ annually for a full-time CD in the US), Designity fills that role.

magier's model is leaner. Your art director provides creative oversight and quality control, while you provide the business context and priorities. The art director reviews every design for quality, consistency, and alignment with the brief before it reaches you. For teams that already have strong internal creative direction and need a reliable production partner, this is sufficient and more cost-effective.

One thing worth noting: Designity rotates specialists per project type while keeping the Creative Director consistent. That means you may work with different designers across projects, which some reviewers praise for bringing fresh perspectives and others note as a drawback for brand consistency. magier assigns a fixed team to your account, so the same art director and designers work on your brand continuously.

Webflow development: where the comparison diverges

‍

If your website runs on Webflow, this is the most important section in this comparison. magier can design a page and build it in Webflow under the same subscription with the same team. Your art director coordinates the handoff between designers and Webflow developers internally, so you don't manage two separate vendors.

Designity can design the page, but you'd need to find a separate Webflow developer to implement it. For SaaS companies and startups whose website is their primary conversion channel, that extra vendor coordination adds time and cost that a combined service eliminates.

If you need a one-off Webflow build rather than ongoing work, magier's one-time project option lets you get a site designed and built without subscribing monthly.

Collaboration, platform, and workflow

‍

Designity's workflow is more hands-on at the strategic level. Your Creative Director leads kickoff calls, builds project timelines, and proactively assigns the right specialists. This is helpful if you want someone thinking about your creative pipeline, not just responding to requests.

magier's workflow is more direct: submit a brief, get results in 48 hours, give feedback to your art director, move to the next task. For teams that know what they need and want fast execution without strategic meetings, this is a more efficient loop.

Reliability and scalability

‍

Designity has a structural advantage on concurrency. The Plus plan allows 2 projects simultaneously, and the Premium plan allows 3. magier processes one active task at a time per pipeline. If you regularly need multiple projects running in parallel, Designity handles that within a single plan, while magier would require adding a second pipeline.

For teams whose workflow is more sequential (finish one task, start the next), magier's model is simpler and less expensive. And for one-off needs that fall outside regular subscription work, magier's one-time project option provides a way to handle specific deliverables without changing your plan.

Risk, compliance, and brand security

‍

Both services operate on standard B2B agreements with monthly cancellation and 7-day notice. One difference worth flagging: Designity's 2-week trial comes with a clause that if you cancel during the trial, you forfeit copyright to all work produced during that period. If you continue to a paid plan, you retain full ownership. This is an unusual structure that's worth reading carefully before starting the trial.

magier doesn't offer a free trial, but the one-time project option serves a similar evaluation purpose: you can commission a specific deliverable with a fixed scope and see the quality and process before committing to a monthly subscription.

Who should choose magier

• Your website runs on Webflow and you need both design and development: magier is a Webflow Premium Partner. Designity does not offer Webflow development as a specific service. If your site is on Webflow, this alone can be the deciding factor.
• You want a lower entry price for design production: magier's design subscription at €2,750/month is roughly half the cost of Designity's Plus plan at $5,995/month. If you don't need a Creative Director or marketing strategy services, magier covers design production at a lower cost.
• You have a clear sense of what your brand needs: magier's art director provides creative oversight and quality control on every task. If your team can set priorities and provide business context, you don't need to pay for the additional strategic layer (campaign concepting, marketing audits, channel strategy) that Designity includes in its price.
• You need a fast, predictable production cycle: magier's 48-hour turnaround on every active task gives you a consistent delivery cadence that doesn't depend on project timelines or Creative Director availability.
• You're not ready for a subscription and want to start with a single project: magier's one-time project option lets you get a specific deliverable (a rebrand, a Webflow site, a design project) without a monthly commitment. Designity does not offer project-based pricing.

Who should choose Designity

• You need marketing services beyond design: If your team needs copywriting, SEO strategy, content marketing, ABM campaigns, and marketing audits alongside design production, Designity covers all of that under one subscription. magier does not offer these services.
• You want to try before you commit: Designity's 2-week risk-free trial with no upfront payment lets you evaluate the Creative Director, the workflow, and the quality before paying. Keep in mind the IP forfeiture clause if you cancel during the trial.
• You need multiple projects running simultaneously: Designity's Plus plan supports 2 concurrent projects and Premium supports 3. If your team regularly runs parallel creative workstreams, this is a practical advantage over magier's one-active-task-per-pipeline model.

Real-world scenarios

These scenarios are pulled from magier's actual case studies. They feature only magier because we have no visibility into how Designity's clients experienced their work.

Namespace (Web3): Namespace needed a complete brand identity built from scratch. magier delivered the full brand at 45% less cost compared to alternatives the company had evaluated. Branding is a service Designity also offers, but at a starting price of $5,995/month. For a growth-stage company, magier delivered brand-level work at a lower price point without requiring a Creative Director layer.

Plancraft (SaaS): Plancraft needed a web redesign to improve conversions. magier handled both the design and the Webflow build under one subscription. The result was a 20% increase in conversion rate. With Designity, the design work could be covered, but the Webflow development would need a separate vendor, adding a coordination layer and a second cost. magier's combined design + Webflow plan at €4,450/month delivered both at a lower price than Designity's design-only Plus plan at $5,995/month.

How magier works

1. Subscribe and get matched with your team: You're paired with a dedicated art director who leads a handpicked team of designers and/or Webflow developers based on your subscription scope.
2. Submit your first request through the dashboard: Briefs follow a structured format, so you can describe what you need in minutes.
3. Prioritize your queue: If you have multiple requests, choose which one gets worked on first.
4. Review and give feedback: Your team delivers first results within 48 hours. You review the work, leave feedback, and request revisions. Your art director reviews every design before it reaches you.
5. Approve and move to the next task: Once a task is final, the team moves to the next one in your queue. All finished files are stored in Figma and on the dashboard.

Not ready for a subscription? magier also offers one-time projects with a fixed scope and deadline for teams that need a specific deliverable first.

Why choose magier

• Design and Webflow development under one roof: Designity offers design and general web development but does not specialize in Webflow. magier is a Webflow Premium Partner and handles both design and Webflow builds, removing the need for a separate development vendor.
• Lower entry price for design production: magier's design subscription at €2,750/month is roughly half the cost of Designity's Plus plan. If your primary need is design execution rather than creative strategy, you get production capacity at a lower cost.
• 48-hour turnaround as a stated commitment: Every active task gets first results within 48 hours, with an update every 48 hours after that. This cadence is guaranteed, not variable.
• No hour caps. magier's unlimited-tasks model has no monthly hour limit. Designity's Plus plan caps at 120 hours per month, after which you need to upgrade or buy add-on capacity.
• Monthly cancellation with no fees: Both services offer monthly cancellation with 7-day notice, but Designity charges $995 to pause. magier has no pause fee. You cancel and resubscribe when you're ready.
• One-time projects for teams not ready to subscribe: If you need a single deliverable before committing to a subscription, magier offers fixed-scope projects. Designity requires a subscription or a trial to start.

So, whom should you choose?

magier and Designity solve the same core problem (getting design work done without hiring in-house) but with different models. Designity adds a Creative Director layer that handles strategy, specialist assignment, and quality control. magier keeps the model simpler: you direct the work, your art director leads the production team and reviews every deliverable before it ships.

If your team needs a Creative Director, marketing strategy, and multi-discipline production under one subscription, Designity covers that. If your team already has a strong sense of what it needs and wants a dedicated art director and production team to execute it with quality oversight, magier is the more practical and cost-effective option.

To see how magier works for your specific situation, you can book a demo. And if you're not ready for a subscription, magier also handles one-time projects with a fixed scope and deadline.

{{cta}}